So I got my hands on a sample yesterday of Serge Noire… any guess where I was shopping?
Serge Noire opens with a bomb of cold incense, a hint of cinnamon and a big ole’ handful of medicinal cloves. It’s a cold aroma with a bizarre “heat” behind it – the spices a complete contrast to what it should be smelling like. There’s a fruity note up top too, maybe some pink & black pepper? – and a growing presence of cumin.
I surprisingly quite like the spice combo – it’s a big oriental on an unexpected base, but the cloves are far too dominant - thankfully I have begun to tolerate and enjoy certain clove notes but the use here is unsettling with the crisp, almost metallic incense underneath. The incense does have a smokiness to it, which is enhanced with a typical Lutens’ cedarwood underneath that smells raw and almost burnt. All together it creates an uncomfortable medicinal smell that whilst would normally to me be charming, is too overloaded on the cloves and cinnamon to be appealing.
The clove does seem to have a floral, carnation effect underneath which softens the edges a little, but in no way enough to consider Serge Noire floral. The pepper from the opening manages to persist far longer than expected, and over time Serge Noire gains this unexpected waxy texture – the incense still providing a cold smoke and the cloves refusing to leave.
A minty note pops up – or maybe it just takes me a long time to want to hunt for something else in here – and continues the cool feel of the opening all the way through the fragrance – the out-of-place heat from cinnamon and maybe nutmeg sitting on the skin in a dry, piercing dust.
What leads into the drydown is mainly an incense/cedar combo with the remains of the heart’s spice basket clinging on, a subtle resinous amber and maybe even a touch of vanilla sweetening what’s left.
It’s hideous
Serge Noire 50ml Serge Lutens – 99 Euros sergelutens.com

Wow! You tackled the clove beast!
Haha! I couldn’t stand it. I have warmed to some cloves though – it was Stephen Jones that changed my mind on the note
and explorations into carnations.
I’m jealous, you make it sound incredible!
I know you like this one
Have you ever smelled papier d’Armenie burning? If you are in Paris it is very easy to find and very cheap. The cheaper, the more authentic. It is the oldest way of scenting a room. To me Serge Noire smells just like this. I love it
I can deal with it on my hand because I can wash it off – making my whole room smell of it I think would make me claw my way through the brick walls with my bare hands
LOL
Actually our review is very alike literally (carnation…vanilla etc)! All taste I suppose.
I can do cumin , but I pass on cloves !
We are very alike then! But surprisingly, there are cloves out there that work – this isn’t one of them
Cloves are for Easter ham not for people!
Unless they are subtle, buzzing with aldehydes, violet and mineral smells a la Stephen Jones
But you’re right – it rarely works
Cloves are perfect for Christmas wrapped around an orange, lemon or lime as a decoration and room freshener. Someone I’m sure out there love this. Now I have to give it a sniff!!!
I think there are a lot of people who love this – I don’t know how though
From start to finish it’s really rough going. Look forward to hearing what you think about it though Houndy
x
[...] constant references to “BO” (body odor) and sweat which I found alarminng. But when Smelly Thoughts – a blogger who adores niche fragrances that are somewhat avant-garde or extreme — [...]